Is This Website Legit? 8 Checks Before You Buy

Quick Answer
No single check proves a website is real, but a few together tell you a lot. Type the address yourself, compare the price to what you expect, look for a real contact address and return policy, search for complaints, and pay by credit card. If a seller says you can only pay with gift cards, wire transfers, payment apps or cryptocurrency, stop. That is a warning sign.
On this page
- What are the 8 checks before I buy?
- Checks 1 to 4: What should I look at on the site itself?
- What does a fake store page look like?
- Checks 5 to 7: What can I check away from the site?
- Check 8: Which way of paying protects me most?
- What should I do if I already paid a fake website?
- Where can I learn more about common scams?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Our Take
- Sources
Key Takeaways
- Fake stores copy real ones, so a nice design proves nothing. Look at the address, the price, the policies and how you are asked to pay.
- Do not trust a link in an ad. Go to a store by typing its address yourself.
- Search the store's name and web address with words like "review," "complaint" or "scam" before you buy.
- Paying by credit card gives you the best protection if something goes wrong, according to the FTC.
- If you already paid, call your card company right away and report it. It is not your fault.
What are the 8 checks before I buy?
Here is the short version. Each check is explained in the next sections, and the picture is easy to print and keep by your computer.
Checks 1 to 4: What should I look at on the site itself?
Check 1: Type the address yourself. Scammers often put ads on social media that copy real brands. The FTC says these ads may show brand name products at unusually low prices, and a click can lead to a fake website built to take your money [2]. If an ad looks like it is from a store you know, close it. Then type that store's address into your browser, or search for the store by name.
Check 2: Read the web address closely. Fake stores often use a long, odd name or an unusual ending. A made-up example is best-deals-outlet[.]shop. (We write it with brackets so it cannot be clicked.) A real store is more likely to have a short, simple name you recognize. Look for small spelling changes, like an extra word or a swapped letter. This is a hint, not proof. A fake store can also have a normal looking address, so keep going through the other checks.
Check 3: Ask if the price makes sense. The FTC warns that expensive brand name items offered at bargain prices could be counterfeit or stolen [1]. A countdown clock or "only 2 left" banner can add pressure. Pressure to act now is one of the four common scam signs described in our hub guide on spotting scams. Compare the price with two or three stores you already know.
Check 4: Find a real address and a way to reach a person. Look for a street address, an email and a phone number. The FTC page says to check the total cost, return rules and shipping promise before you buy, and these are usually found in the store's terms or privacy policy pages [1]. If the contact page is missing, or the only option is a form, think twice. If a phone number is listed, you can look the business up by name to see whether others mention the same details. Do not rely on the site's own words as proof.
What does a fake store page look like?
The picture below is a made-up example. It is not a real store. It shows several signs that can appear together. Seeing one of them does not mean a store is fake, but seeing several should make you stop.
Checks 5 to 7: What can I check away from the site?
Check 5: Read the return and shipping rules. Before you buy, find out who pays for return shipping, how many days you have to send the item back, and whether there is a restocking fee. The FTC also says that if a seller does not promise a ship date, it generally must ship your order within 30 days under an FTC rule [1]. A store with no policy at all, or one that is vague, is a reason to shop elsewhere.
Check 6: Look for reviews away from the site. Reviews on a store's own pages are easy to fake. The FTC says not to rely on star ratings alone, because some reviews and ratings are fake or misleading. It suggests checking several sources and looking at who wrote the review. Most useful of all, the FTC advises searching the company name or the web address along with the words "complaint," "review" or "scam" to see what other buyers report [2]. Your card company, your bank or a family member who shops online a lot can also be good people to ask. Think of reviews as one clue and not the whole answer. If a store has pages of glowing praise but nobody outside its own site mentions it, that gap is worth noticing. If you are unsure, ask a friend or a grown child to look at the store with you. A second pair of eyes often catches something you missed, and there is no shame in asking. Please skip any website that claims to give you an instant "safe or unsafe" score. We do not recommend those as proof either way.
Check 7: Do not trust the padlock alone. Many people look for "https" and a small padlock in the address bar. The FTC says to look for "https," but also says it does not prove a site is legitimate, because scammers can use encryption too [1]. The padlock means your connection is private. It does not tell you who is on the other end.
Check 8: Which way of paying protects me most?
This check matters most, because it decides what you can do if something goes wrong. The FTC says paying by credit card best protects you and your money in case of a scam or if something else goes wrong [1]. With a credit card you can dispute a charge for being billed twice, never getting the item, or getting the wrong or a damaged item.
The warning side is just as clear. The FTC says never to buy from online sellers who insist you can only pay with gift cards, wire transfers, payment apps or cryptocurrency. Those are payment methods scammers prefer, because they are hard to reverse.
Our sources cover credit cards. If you plan to use a debit card or another method, ask your bank or card company what protection it offers before you buy. For the bank or card company phone number, always use the number on the back of your card or on your statement.
What should I do if I already paid a fake website?
First, take a breath. This happens to careful people, because fake stores look real on purpose. It is not your fault. Here is what to do, in order.
- Call your card company right away. Use the number on the back of your card or on your statement. Say you want to dispute the charge.
- Send a written notice too. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) says to send a written billing error notice to the card company within 60 calendar days of the charge appearing on your statement, and that the company then has 30 days to confirm it got your notice [3]. Even if you already paid the charge, you can still dispute it. The CFPB adds that you probably will not get the money back until the company decides in your favor.
- Do not send more money. If a "support agent" says you must pay a fee to get a refund, stop. Do not reply to them or call them back.
- Keep your records. Save the web address, screenshots, your order confirmation, emails and your statements, as the FTC suggests.
- Report it. Tell the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov [4]. Our step by step reporting guide lists other places to report.
- Protect your accounts. If you typed a password, change it, and turn on two step verification.
We cannot promise you will get your money back. It depends on your card company's decision and on how you paid. If you paid with a gift card, a wire or crypto, our what to do after being scammed tool shows the first steps for each. See also the sections on wire transfers and crypto.
Where can I learn more about common scams?
Fake stores are only one kind of scam. Scammers also use texts, calls and emails, and the same warning signs show up again and again: someone pretends to be a business you trust, there is a problem or a prize, you are pushed to act fast, and you are told to pay in a way that is hard to undo. Our scams library explains many of them, and our recovery guides help if money has already moved. For ways to stay ahead of scammers before anything happens, see our protection guides. You can also browse all of our guides.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a padlock or "https" mean a website is safe?
No. The padlock means the connection is encrypted. The FTC says it does not prove a site is legitimate, because scammers can use encryption too.
Can I trust a website because it has lots of good reviews?
Not by that alone. The FTC says some reviews and ratings are fake or misleading. Check reviews on other sites, and search the store's name with the word "complaint."
What if the site looks professional?
A polished look is easy to copy. Use the checks above, especially the address, the price and the payment method.
Where can I check a quick list when I am in a hurry?
Use our red flag checklist. It is short and also works for texts, emails and calls.
Our Take
We think the most useful habit is the simplest one: decide how you will pay before you fall in love with a price. If a store only takes payment methods that cannot be reversed, no discount is worth it. We also think the padlock tip gives a false sense of safety. The FTC's own advice puts more weight on the price, the payment method and what other buyers say. We like that approach because it does not depend on spotting a perfect fake. A fake store wants you to hurry. If a site makes you feel rushed, that feeling is itself information. You can read how we pick and check our sources on our fact checking page. More scam types are in our scams library.
Sources
- Online Shopping. Federal Trade Commission, 2023.
- How to avoid an online shopping scam this holiday season. Federal Trade Commission, 2025.
- How do I dispute a charge on my credit card bill?. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
- What To Do if You Were Scammed. Federal Trade Commission, 2026.
Scam Signals is an independent site, not a government agency. Phone numbers and report links come only from official websites and show the date we checked them. Never call a number given to you in a suspicious message. Spotted an error? Tell us.
